||| FROM ORCAS ISLAND PRIDE |||
| I filled my ballot out this morning, and it reminded me of how many of you showed up to see the candidates for council and learn about the awful initiatives on the ballot this year. We so appreciate every one of you. |
|
Couldn’t make it? That’s okay! That’s what this email is for. We break down the initiatives and the harm they’re causing below. |
|
We strongly encourage you to vote “no” on all three initiatives on this year’s Washington state ballot: IP26-645, IL26-001, and IL20-638. |
|
IL26-001 The policy requires school staff to inform parents if a student identifies as LGBTQA+ and permits adults to access private school counseling records. Additionally, it eliminates the requirement for schools to promptly notify parents if their child is a victim of a crime at school. This will discourage students experiencing bullying or abuse from seeking help and break the trust required to build a supportive learning environment for young people in our community. |
| IL20-638 forces elementary, middle, and high school girls who want to play sports to prove they were assigned female at birth. That means they have to go through a medically unnecessary genital exam every year. (Genetic testing could work too, but most families can’t afford that.)
The argument that trans girls will always beat cis girls is based on the sexist idea that boys are always stronger than girls. Trans girls who are on puberty blockers or have been on cross-sex hormones for 1-2 years don’t have the supposed advantages that testosterone gives. Also, only about 5-10 trans young people play sports in Washington. |
| IP26-645 will eliminate crucial funding for education, childcare, and healthcare by repealing the billionaires’ tax.
All 3 initiatives are sponsored by a single billionaire. |
| Thank you to Libby from No Hate in WA State for speaking on IL26-001 and IL20-638. Thank you to Katherine and Jennifer for speaking with the Orcas community and answering questions. Thank you to Amy Vanderwarker for speaking on the danger of repealing IP26-645.
Remember: vote “No” on all three initiatives on this year’s Washington state ballot: IP26-645, IL26-001, and IL20-638.
|
**If you are reading theOrcasonian for free, thank your fellow islanders. If you would like to support theOrcasonian CLICK HERE to set your modestly-priced, voluntary subscription. Otherwise, no worries; we’re happy to share with you.**
“Boys are always stronger than girls” — exactly. They are.
Overall, boys are bigger and stronger than girls, taller with longer bones, broader shoulders, and narrower hips. Boys have larger muscle mass, their muscles are built differently, and attach differently, and receive movement signals differently. They have bigger hearts, bigger lung surface, and carry more oxygen. Girls are more susceptible to concussive injuries, have lower impact resistance in our neck muscles and more delicate brain structures. No drugs will fully reverse boys’ advantages (although these drugs will ruin their health and shorten their lives).
It is NOT sexist to acknowledge these facts. Boys and girls are different; men and women are different. We women can give birth and have better peripheral vision (better for guarding toddlers), for instance. And thank goodness for that! Let’s celebrate those differences. It’s not sexist to do that; we are simply different.
54 years ago, progressives cheered for Title IX, a law that *finally* treats female students and athletes as people in our own right, to have fair and equal opportunity in education and in sport. Now we have faux-“progressives” who pretend that sex doesn’t matter and say that girls don’t deserve fairness, safety, dignity, and privacy. It shocks me every day.
And, a simple sports physical, required for all students to participate in sport, worked perfectly fine for 5 decades until this initiative was added to the ballot and everyone suddenly lost their minds. It still does. No special “exams” are needed.
If you want to see just how many times girls have been impacted in Washington State by those who obviously do not care one tiny bit about women and girls, go to https://hecheated.org/Totals_high-school_results and select Washington.
I happily voted YES on I-638 and I-001 and hope you will too. Women and girls matter just as much as men and boys.
Well said Elizabeth. Common sense must prevail once in a while in our hyper-reactive, defensive social equality discussions. The use of the word HATE on the vote NO signs lumping all three initiatives is hyperbolic, inaccurate and divisive. I voted as you did, and trust that most reasonable voters might have voted the same. No issue is so simple as to approach being black or white. I voted for fairness and protection of biologically female student athletes through high school in an era of wider and entirely appropriate gender-based rights battles. Thousands of biologically female youth have lost opportunities and recognition of achievement in WA due to competition by a couple dozen biological male students as a result of school district spineless reasoning and fear of socio-political backlash in public. A state law is needed.
A child under 18, no matter who they claim to be or how they want to be respectfully defined, unless legally separated, is under parental control that cannot hope to be effectively performed if important information is sealed. Parental rights must be protected unless specifically constrained.
Since it would be near impossible for most people to become ultra-wealthy (by legal means) where the numerous direct tax breaks and indirect benefits from public tax dollars improving infrastructure did not exist then a higher tax rate must be imposed for the greater public good.
Remember the thing about reasoned opinions…everyone has one. Vote yours!
I appreciate the well-thought-out and rational comments already written. I think there are so many more of us who see the harm being caused by boys (what the author of the article calls “trans girls”) to girls in Washington state sports. Sadly, the vitriol and name-calling that so often accompanies pointing out the truth of the situation deters many people from speaking up. So THANK YOU to Beth and Steve.
Regarding the statement: “Also, only about 5-10 trans young people play sports in Washington.” First of all, there are far more than that in WA state, and many more in states all across the country. Check out this link to see the more than 200 spots stolen from girls by boys just in WA state:
https://hecheated.org/Totals_high-school_results
The bigger question is: why are any boys playing in girls’ sports? Even just 5-10 boys can take many awards, medals, opportunities and scholarships away from girls. Not to mention how discouraging it is to girls to have to compete against a boy. And, to the author, how many would be too many? You say there are “only” 5-10 trans girls (boys) playing in girls’ sports in WA state. And remember that’s just one state. How many would be too many? 100? 1000? And while there is ample evidence to show that taking cross-sex hormones does NOT completely diminish boys’ physical advantages, you don’t mention whether those “only” 5-10 trans girls (boys) are taking hormones.
Boys are, in general, stronger than girls. That is a fact. Will girls sometimes beat boys? Of course. But on average, yes, boys have many physical advantages over girls. This was already discussed above by a previous commenter. It is dangerous to girls to say that is a sexist idea.
It’s time to stand up for girls’ dignity, safety, and fairness. We must stop lying to boys and telling them they are girls just because they say so (and even if they take cross sex hormones, which is incredibly damaging to their physical and mental health) and stop putting boys’ feelings above girls’ very real oppression. Vote YES on 638.