||| FROM ELISABETH ROBSON |||
San Juan County has adopted a policy governing the use of generative AI by County employees. It lists approved AI tools, including Microsoft Copilot, Claude, Grammarly, and Canva, and also includes tools such as Verkada security cameras with facial recognition and KnowBe4 AIDA that could be used for profiling. Residents deserve to understand what this policy means in practice.
Here are some questions to ask our candidates, County Council members, and other elected officials:
What problem is the County trying to solve? Which specific services or tasks require AI, and why can’t they be handled without it?
What will this cost taxpayers? Has the County calculated the full cost of licenses, training, security, monitoring, audits, maintenance, and dealing with errors or data breaches? How will it know whether AI actually saves money, particularly during the current budget crisis?
What information will these systems collect or process? What protections prevent residents’ personal information, tax records, court records, or other sensitive data from being exposed or misused?
What does approval of these tools authorize? What exactly will each application do? Is facial recognition currently in use, and if so, where, for what purposes, and under what restrictions?
Who is checking whether these systems work safely and accurately? Who audits their use, identifies bias or errors, and is responsible when something goes wrong?
Will the public see the audit results? The policy describes internal reporting but does not specify a public reporting schedule or public portal for AI audit findings. Will the County publish regular reports on which tools are used, what they cost, what they do, and what problems they cause?
Who will handle public-records requests about AI? The County has already cited staffing constraints in discontinuing the Sheriff’s weekly media-line report. How will it handle additional requests for AI-related records without compromising other public services?
What environmental costs have been considered? Has the County assessed the energy, water, resource use, and infrastructure required by these systems, and compared those costs with non-AI alternatives?
Can the County explain in precise detail how this policy will be enforced? Who is accountable for compliance, how often will the policy be reviewed, and what happens if an employee or vendor violates it?
Why adopt this policy now? Wouldn’t it be prudent to establish the actual need, full costs, environmental consequences, and public-accountability mechanisms before expanding the County’s use of AI?
These are questions about public spending, privacy, transparency, environmental responsibility, and the kind of community we want to live in. Please ask our candidates and elected officials for specific answers, not just assurances that AI will make County government more efficient.
A more in-depth look at my concerns about this policy can be found at The Panopticon Has Come For My County.
**If you are reading theOrcasonian for free, thank your fellow islanders. If you would like to support theOrcasonian CLICK HERE to set your modestly-priced, voluntary subscription. Otherwise, no worries; we’re happy to share with you.**
Thank you Elizabeth for posing timely questions about generative AI. I do not understand much of this big change being forced on the world and certainly have doubts. Here in our tiny county already struggling to sustain itself and hold on to a semblance of rural character I can imagine the genie being let out of the bottle and greater confusion and hidden costs in our already unsustainable level of government services. I fear claims of saving money with generative AI seeping into everything imaginable without a clear understanding of effective constraints and fire walls. What about concise statements of protecting privacy? Our candidates race is certainly energetic and lively, but too far along for these important questions that have not been addressed at all to my knowledge. The county Manager should enlighten us in public media releases. Sooner rather than later.
Thank you, Elisabeth, for raising these important points about use of generative AI in the County public services. While there may be short-term savings, the costs of making sure that errors do not occur and that our privacy is respected may overwhelm these savings. We simply do not know the answers at present. And I am deeply concerned, with you, about establishing a Panopticon system in these islands.
I must have missed a beat. This is the first I’ve heard or read about the County’s “generative AI use policy.” Couldn’t find it on the County’s website or previously noted in the Orcasonian, so thanks for the link, Elisabeth. It’s a bit of a late heads-up, since the Council adopted the policy last May; but, yes, shouldn’t there have been some public announcement by the County? The policy pertains, as far as I understand, to the County’s internal use of AI for its administrative purposes, which may have real benefits in information access and efficiency. But how does that affect its interaction with its citizens? Public records? Good questions about the costs. Given the extent of current, and local concern about AI, yes, I hope the County and Council candidates will respond.
One additional point: Steve charitably characterizes the candidates race as being “energetic and lively.” Even after attending one of the candidates’ forums, I have yet to hear either candidate substantively address any specific issue that may be a matter of local controversy.
Thank you, Elisabeth, for this important piece. As soon as this news hit my radar last week, I emailed Justin to talk with him about it, which I will be doing soon. I’ve been fairly active in pushing back against the use of generative AI, in working to stop the construction of more hyper-scale AI data centers, and in conjunction with that, working to stop the construction of small modular nuclear reactors (SMNRs) in our state, which would be constructed with taxpayer dollars, but the energy produced would go to power those hyper-scale data centers. I’m very concerned about both the hyper-scale data centers and the proposals for new nuclear plants, which are fraught with problems, from the extended timelines to huge cost overruns to the massive production of nuclear waste. The hyper-scale data centers consume a huge amount of energy and use a massive amount of water. I am guilty of not attending enough of the County Council meetings and this resolution totally got past me. I have been reading and hearing absolutely hair-raising reports about the hacking (which has already taken place by AI) and the level of destruction that AI has the potential to do to our world, including the destruction of humanity. I wish this were hyperbole, but it is not. Generative AI has been forced on our whole society by a small handful of extremely wealthy “tech oligarchs” and the federal government has refused to put any guardrails on them. This is completely unacceptable, and I’m glad to see people across the country pushing back against further construction of these hyper-scale data centers. We are all in this together, in San Juan County, in Washington State, and across our country. I urge the County Council to rethink the wisdom of introducing generative AI into our county.