||| FROM COLIN WILLIAMS |||
At a recent community lunch, the conversation turned, as it does this time of year, to the election. Doug McDonald mentioned that his nephew is Judge Sean O’Donnell, a candidate for Position 4 on the Washington State Supreme Court. I admitted I’d already marked Ian Birk on my ballot.
That evening I went home and I read deeper into their positions and asked myself why I’d chosen one candidate over the other. The answer changed my vote.
I come at this as a self-represented litigant who has spent time in King County Superior Court. When you stand in a courtroom without a lawyer, you learn quickly that the judge’s politics don’t matter. What matters is whether the judge listens, and whether the law is applied the same way to you as to everyone else. A parent’s access to their child should never depend on the judge(s) perception of that parent’s views. That principle is impartiality, and it’s what this race is
about.
Our own San Juan County Democrats endorsed Birk, while Whatcom County Democrats have endorsed both candidates. O’Donnell has also been recommended by Republican groups, and that support has been turned against him. He’s been pressed to disavow it and labeled a partisan in a flood of mailers. His response is the one I want from a judge: he won’t write off voters because of their politics. A judicial candidate with support from both sides of the aisle isn’t a partisan. That’s exactly what we should hope for.
His record backs that up. He has been a King County Superior Court judge since 2013, is a past president of the Superior Court Judges Association, and served as chief judge of the county’s Unified Family Court. He helped create King County’s protection order court and worked to make sure people who don’t speak English have interpreters.
More than 240 judges across Washington endorse him, including several I recognize from my own time in King County courtrooms.
There’s a local connection too: his campaign’s mailing address is a PO Box right here in Eastsound.
I hope Judge O’Donnell wins. I also hope that, as a justice, he’ll keep working to make our courts easier to navigate for people who look to represent themselves. The Supreme Court writes the rules every litigant must follow, and access to justice should not depend on your wealth or your political identity.
Ballots are due November 3.
**If you are reading theOrcasonian for free, thank your fellow islanders. If you would like to support theOrcasonian CLICK HERE to set your modestly-priced, voluntary subscription. Otherwise, no worries; we’re happy to share with you.**
Thank you for writing this! I am Judge Sean O’Donnell’s treasurer—thus the Orcas PO Box. I have known him for over forty years, and I’ve also served as his bailiff in King County Superior Court. He is one of the best people I’ve ever known. He is decent, kind, honest, smart, hard-working and compassionate, and has served the people of King County and Washington State for decades. There is no one I trust more to be fair and follow the law. Thank you for seeing beyond what the mailers have said. They have been terribly misleading and unfair to him. Vote for Sean O’Donnell for position 4!
I also hope that Judge O’Donnell wins. If a party wants to recommend someone, that’s their choice. Burke requested Democratic backing, thereby politicizing himself. As I understand it, O’Donnell did not request party backing.
The politicization of the bench has recently come to the fore. We should not encourage it.
On the other hand (from a trusted friend in the know)–
Position 4
Sean O’Donnell
https://www.odonnellforjustice.com/
As of 6-20-26 he has collected $197,169.47 in campaign contributions.
Ah, and here is where we get the info. While he has received donations from a fair amount of
lawyers and judges, the most and the largest donations are from real estate, insurance, financial
advisors, and other large financial/real estate corporations.
He’s been 13 years a King County Superior Court judge
What focus I could find (and it was hard) is on victims’ rights, courthouse security, making
courts relevant and accessible.
His website appears to be focused entirely on endorsements. He’s endorsed by a whole lot of
Superior Court judges all over the state, and a lot of lower level politicians. What I’m not seeing
is any statement of principles. That definitely bothers me. He claims he always puts people first
and will never be influenced by special interests. I wonder how that relates to the large sums
donated by all those large business interests.
His opponent’s contributions and the Independent expenditure group opposing Judge ‘Donnell come primarily from personal injury attorneys who make millions suing the state. Please see https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/times-watchdog/wa-counties-desperate-to-fix-rising-lawsuit-costs/ and
https://www.seattletimes.com/opinion/editorials/watch-out-state-supreme-court-pos-4-candidate-hits-new-lows/
As for his values, I think twenty five years of public service and this statement cover it: https://www.odonnellforjustice.com/why-i-am-running.
That all being said. After an exhaustive review of both of these candidates campaigns (including campaign contributors, as well as their their past experience), I too, will be voting for Sean O’Donnell.
Ann I hope that we have the opportunity to meet and talk about your experience regardless of the election results (hopint of course O’Donnell wins!). If you’d be interested feel free to email me at colin.williams.orcas@gmail.com