Non-lethal seal deterrent shows promise at Hood Canal Bridge, where up to half of young steelhead die
||| FROM LONG LIVE THE KINGS |||
SEATTLE – Up to half of the young steelhead that reach the Hood Canal Bridge on their way to the ocean do not make it past. Long Live the Kings, the Port Gamble S’Klallam Tribe, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), and their partners have spent recent years testing ways to improve those odds, and the results, released today, are mixed. One approach shows real promise; another fell short, and together they point to the bridge itself as the problem that ultimately has to be solved.
The bridge’s current design slows juvenile steelhead as they try to pass through on their migration to the ocean, and harbor seals have learned to feed where the fish linger, especially at the bridge’s corners. To improve the odds for juvenile steelhead, the partners tested two approaches: an acoustic startle device meant to keep seals away, and fish guidance structures meant to help fish move past the bridge more quickly.
During Phase 2, researchers from the Port Gamble S’Klallam Tribe evaluated an acoustic startle device in partnership with Oceans Initiative, designed to trigger a flight response in seals. Testing showed that underwater seal detections near the device decreased by as much as 80 percent, with consistent results observed over two years. These findings suggest the device could be a promising tool for reducing seal activity near the bridge. However, each device is effective only over a short distance, meaning numerous devices would be needed to cover the bridge’s 1.5-mile length. Additional research is needed to determine whether the technology could be effective at that scale.
“The scale of harbor seal predation on steelhead at the bridge is larger than what could be addressed using the temporary bridge modifications employed in our study,” said Megan Moore, Research Fisheries Biologist at NOAA. “A new bridge design without a passage barrier would be the ideal solution, but mitigating the problem in the meantime is essential to stop further steelhead population decline.”
Fish guidance structures were installed to increase fish survival by expediting movement in areas known to delay passage and reducing eddy formation (swirling currents). The studies showed that the structures significantly reduced eddy formation in the corners of the bridge and prevented seals from using these corners for feeding. However, during the deployment period, scientists did not observe a significant improvement in steelhead survival as the fish attempted to pass the bridge on their migration through the Salish Sea.
Resource limitations meant the structures could be installed in only two out of the four corner areas, potentially reducing their overall effectiveness. With additional structures and design adjustments, their effectiveness could increase; however, given the high operating cost, it is not a responsible path to advance the study without a regulatory mandate.
“This work has reaffirmed that addressing steelhead mortality at the Hood Canal Bridge is a complex challenge, which is why we are now engaging in conversations around a long-term bridge redesign,” said Shaara Ainsley, Associate Director of Projects at Long Live the Kings. “Our collaborative approach and range of experiments, including fish guidance structures and promising acoustic startle devices have generated valuable insights, even when certain methods did not yield the hoped-for results.”
The decade-long effort to address fish mortality issues caused by the Hood Canal Bridge has been a collaborative process with federal, state, local, and Tribal governments. The hope is that this will continue as we work together to implement interim measures and long-term solutions.
“For the Port Gamble S’Klallam Tribe, protecting salmon and steelhead is deeply connected to the health of our region’s ecosystems and the well-being of future generations,” said Hans Daubenberger, Senior Research Scientist for the Port Gamble S’Klallam Tribe. “These measures, while important, only treat the symptoms. The underlying cause is the bridge itself, and only a redesign that addresses the barrier will resolve it.”
Daubenberger notes that even once a replacement is underway, planning, environmental review, funding, and construction could take 10 to 20 years. Until then, continued testing of interim measures offers the best chance to reduce harm.
For more information about the Hood Canal Bridge assessment, visit the webpage. Read the full Phase 2 assessment report for details on the study’s findings and recommendations.
**If you are reading theOrcasonian for free, thank your fellow islanders. If you would like to support theOrcasonian CLICK HERE to set your modestly-priced, voluntary subscription. Otherwise, no worries; we’re happy to share with you.**
Leave A Comment