||| FROM DARRELL KIRK |||


As the Trump administration continues to settle into power, many islanders have expressed concerns about America’s democratic foundations. Some political scientists have revived discussions of Ernst Fraenkel’s concept of the “dual state” – where democratic institutions exist alongside parallel power structures that operate outside normal constraints. One such article was published in The Atlantic: “America is Watching the Rise of a Dual State.”

While comparisons to pre-war Germany should be approached with extreme caution, the concept offers a framework to examine potential threats to democratic norms. All administrations face the temptation to consolidate power, and citizens must remain vigilant regardless of which party holds office.

Milton Friedman famously declared “government is the problem,” advocating for limited government intervention. While reducing bureaucracy and wasteful spending are legitimate policy goals, we must distinguish between responsible governance reforms and potentially dangerous power consolidation that undermines institutional checks and balances.

History shows democracies can erode gradually when independent institutions are weakened, media is delegitimized, and an “us versus them” mentality replaces civic discourse. The concerns aren’t about policy disagreements but about protecting democratic guardrails.

Here in the San Juans, our community may seem removed from national politics, but we have meaningful ways to protect democratic norms:

  1. Support local journalism and reliable news sources. Subscribe to publications that maintain journalistic integrity and fact-based reporting.
  2. Engage with local government. Attend council meetings, participate in public forums, and hold local officials accountable to democratic principles regardless of party.
  3. Build community resilience. Strong communities with active civic participation are less vulnerable to divisive politics. Our island’s traditions of volunteerism and mutual aid are democratic strengths.
  4. Practice respectful dialogue across political differences. Democracy thrives when citizens engage meaningfully with diverse viewpoints.
  5. Support organizations defending democratic institutions, transparency, and voting rights.
The strength of American democracy has always depended on engaged citizens committed to our constitutional principles. From town halls in colonial New England to civil rights movements, positive change has often started in small communities like ours.
I am in awe of the “small” silent protests I’ve witnessed over the past few months on the corner of downtown East Sound near Brown Bear Bakery. What started with a few Islanders continues to grow each week and have a profound effect on local citizens and guests who visit from all over Washington State.  Soon Islanders will meet on the Village Green in Eastsound for the “Hands Off! Mass Mobilization” on April 5.

Whatever your political beliefs, preserving the integrity of our democratic institutions serves all Americans and paints a vivid canvas for others to ponder and enjoy. President Jimmy Carter said : “The best way to enhance freedom in other lands is to demonstrate here that our democratic system is worth of emulation” Our islands may be small, but our commitment to democratic principles can ripple far beyond our shores.



**If you are reading theOrcasonian for free, thank your fellow islanders. If you would like to support theOrcasonian CLICK HERE to set your modestly-priced, voluntary subscription. Otherwise, no worries; we’re happy to share with you.**