— from Cathy Ellis —
Perhaps some year in the near future, we as a community might find an alternative to our usual Eastsound 4th of July celebration. Keep the party, yes, perhaps do a brilliant laser show instead, which could still be awesome, big, bright, fun!
Or, initiate a slight change, switch to fireworks that are set off by compressed air, not gunpowder.
Or, let’s go further. Our holiday celebration is made of giant flammable objects, exploding for sheer joy. Explosions remind me of war, not joy. Besides the negative effects to wildlife, smoke and ash in the air contain a variety of heavy metals.
Let’s ask ourselves…..Is a short display of pyrotechnic entertainment really worth needlessly polluting our environment?
By switching to laser shows, as some communities have done, would at least remove the debris falling into the ocean, as well as the noise pollution for our wildlife. Can we be sensitive to our native species? Can we avoid the mess left behind from the fireworks fall-out, in our Sound and on our beach at Waterfront Park.
Last July 4th, at midnight, just after the end of Eastsound’s fireworks, a friend and I paddled kayaks into the sound, near Indian Island; we noted lots of fall-out debris. It was disgraceful–numerous tiny bits of plastic debris from our “joyful” explosions.
I have no idea if fireworks actually frighten the native species that are living, foraging, nesting, singing, breeding, sleeping in or near Eastsound. But, if our pets are any indicator, these events are a big stressor. This yearly “fun” is an explosive, noisy, bright, unpredictable, negative pollution event to all creatures. The health-related stress it potentially causes is unimaginable, let alone the accumulation of toxic fall-out.
It is also hard for me to forget the serious problems associated with people (including kids) in third world countries who make these explosives. The downside of pyrotechnics is carnage. Structure fires, skin burns, mangled digits and death come with the production. China produces more than any other country. They use more of them then we do. So this production-carnage cycle will continue. I simply prefer that my community not be part of it.
Don’t forget the unacceptable number of people who injure themselves here at home with personal firework “fun”. As an ER nurse in Oregon for 30 years, there were too many of these “accidents” during this holiday.
Eventual changes in our annual 4th of July fireworks celebration could be a move toward “sustainability,” a word used often these days. But words and talk are easy. There is nothing sustainable about creatures who have their entire world temporarily exploding over them…confusing, startling sights, sounds and smells, negative effects some species can ill afford.
Any changes toward more culturally appropriate activities would say something about our community. Neighbors and visitors alike are here because we love the natural beauty. We can show we really do care about the creatures we share our world with. We can “walk our talk”.
So let’s start this community conversation now. Perhaps future 4th of July celebrations can be safer for our wild critters, while at the same time continuing to bring tourist business and guests.
Let’s move toward being more sensitive citizens of our modern world, starting here at home, next 4th of July.
**If you are reading theOrcasonian for free, thank your fellow islanders. If you would like to support theOrcasonian CLICK HERE to set your modestly-priced, voluntary subscription. Otherwise, no worries; we’re happy to share with you.**
Well said, Cathy. Thank you.
Yes, PLEASE… How did we ever choose to celebrate by scaring the animals and anyone who has been in a war? I had a dog who would curl up and try to hide in the corner of our shower stall during the fireworks…I expect there are a few veterans who do the same so that we can have our celebration of what they fought for — for us… Makes very little sense to me. Merry
Explosive, Cathy! Well put, bang-up job! I agree wholeheartedly. (And besides, I get my fill of fireworks every day of the year, from religious worldwide wing nuts and self-righteous zealots firing off in all directions!)
While held prisoner by Admiral Cockburn in 1814, watching Ft. McHenry defend Baltimore, Francis Scott Key penned the Star Spangled Banner. He noted the “rockets red glare, bombs bursting in air.” It is likely that fireworks on July 4th are intended to commemorate and remind us of the fight for independence, both in the Revolutionary War and in the War of 1812 (when the Brits nearly crushed us…) Of course pyrotechnics being used as part of celebration date back thousands of years and are not an American invention…
I 100% agree. It’s awful what fireworks do to our pets, wildlife, veterans, and other folks with anxiety disorders….
The fireworks are not what bring visitors to our islands, and not having fireworks won’t result in any real loss of business. I know for a fact that most businesses in Eastsound I’ve talked to acknowledge that sales on the actual 4th aren’t very good for those that choose to stay open later in the afternoon/evening… All that money the Chamber gathers for the event could be directed somewhere else SO easily….!
I fully agree.
This is the first year in a long time that the oystercatchers on Indian Island have successfully reared a chick. I’m not sure what will happen to it after all the explosions tonight (?).
Thanks for suggesting a laser light show, Cathy. With all our talented minds on Orcas Island, I know that this community could come up with something more unique and less destructive than the standard fireworks display on Independence Day. After all, how many visitors choose to come to Orcas Island because of it’s fireworks display? Probably very few. And how many islanders will choose to stay home tonight? Probably a lot (me included).
Now give me a light show with Orca whales and salmon swimming in our night sky,…. I’d actually come to see that!
Wouldn’t you?
Too much warring around the world. More and more people, more and more stuff. It seems much has to change to keep our planet live able. Sustainable. This tradition is one that needs rethinking. The concept to celebrate with “bombs bursting in air” is outdated…the competitive side of America wants shock and awe and as so often the case goes overboard …..bigger, noisier,, more. The wake left behind is not pretty.
I am all for it ! Bring on the laser shows and skip the pollution. It’s about time we evolved and forgot about celebrating previous wars with our fireworks.
I would vote for a laser show but it should(no, it MUST!) have music. It could be extremely memorable and moving and friendly for ALL! A music/laser show paying tribute to our veterans, our glorious country/countryside and all the different, beautiful races and faces of people from all walks of life!
I would be so very proud to be part of such a statement!!!
Happy 4th everyone!
Maggie
I’ve thought this for years! Thank you for making the idea public Cathy.
And let’s not forget our veterans and others who have been through war. My mother spent her teen and young adult years in Europe during World War II, and until she died last year, fireworks and low-flying planes made her throw up. A close friend is a Vietnam vet. I spent one 4th of July with him, and never again do I want to see that kind of body-response to nearby explosions.
If celebrating the 4th of July is about patriotism, let’s celebrate everybody in our great country, including veterans and refugees.
Yes!!! Thank you Cathy.
As we have with so many other things, it would be wonderful for San Juan County to set a new millennium trend toward a much needed change in this country for all the reasons so eloquently stated above.
We in America have very few “traditions” left. At the rate we are going, with suggestions like this, soon we will have none. There are people that the “Stars Stripe” insult, do we do away with it? I believe most prior military folks believe they served to make sure we in America could continue our traditions. But, they served to protect your right to say any thing “strikes your fancy”.
Very well said Cathy, and thank you! Years ago our family went to the Grand Coulee Dam laser light show and it was spectacular.If we were voting on this I would definitely vote yes. And as for the laser light show at Grand Coulee you had to get there early to park because that show is so popular. Maybe more of us would attend again if it was that instead of fireworks.
Totally agree, Cathy, and it is time to make a change. What can 2017 bring? Lance, and the Chamber, your leadership is appreciated. Let’s create a better 4th on Orcas Island.
Way to go Cathy ! Your words are something to celebrate . Yeah. I used to love the fire works, but as I have matured I find it somewhat upsetting internally. Too much.
I lost my dog one year, as I came home late and neighbors had already started shooting off fireworks. He was not found until days later, adopted by a neighbor as he did not have his collar on. We always try and keep pets in the house for the big night. Then there was the time the firework went into the cliff in Deer Harbor and started a fire up the bank of the cliff. The zillion dollar house up above had to get rescued by firefighters in the dark wood trying to get out there. Dangerous. It is really a shock on the system and what an expense.
We really could do better. I think it would be great to start a new trend for the 4th of July celebrations. Conscience, commitment to the environment and peace in the human and animal kingdom. Music and Light show does sound like a good alternative.
“And for the support of this Declaration with a firm reliance on the protection of divine providence, we mutually pledge to each other our lives, our fortunes, and our sacred honor.”
Stereotypes are dangerous…“China produces more than any other country. They use more of them then we do. So this production-carnage cycle will continue…” This is a quite strong conclusion that doesn’t hold up to factual trends on the ground in China.
Fireworks, reputedly the 1,400 year-old invention of a monk named Li Tian, have long been a staple to Spring Festival (Chinese New Year) and other celebrations across China. Originally designed to scare off bad spirits with their loud sounds and bright flashes, fireworks have evolved alongside technology and culture into a celebratory tool with a festive sparkle. Fireworks in China are primarily a matter of individual expression…relatively speaking, there are far fewer organized displays as compared to the United States.
Despite the millennium-old status of fireworks, contemporary Chinese culture, bad air and ‘carnage’ are clashing. Usage regulations and restrictions are increasingly common. Some 530 Chinese cities now impose limitations on fireworks with more than 130 banning their use entirely. Nanjing, a city of 8+ million and the former capital, is at the forefront of cities banning fireworks – a list that grew in 2016 to include Shanghai’s urban core. Notably, the public has received bans in such large cities positively.
So no, the ‘production-carnage cycle’ is not a fait accompli…the issues surrounding fireworks represent a nexus of cultural, technological, ecological and societal considerations…but if a city the size of Shanghai can turn 180 degrees against 1,000+ years of history, certainly our Orcas community can have a diverse and respectful debate about our celebratory future…
And while we’re at it, do all we can to educate folks out in the hinterlands (AKA anywhere a few miles or more from town) to stop firing extremely loud, damaging and illegal fireworks.
Yes, Tracy, it is very difficult to convince July 4th visitors to Sea Acres that fireworks here on Orcas really are illegal when there is a big show going on in town. And when the local police turn a blind eye out here. I’m exhausted today after sitting up all night with my two dogs trying to convince them that the world is not ending…it takes many hours to calm them after the noise stops! Merry
All of us seem to a little different way that we celebrate the 4th of july, I for one think about those were here before and how the earth was treated. Perhaps remembering that we are part of the earth the we live on and treating the planet, the animals ,plants,and maybe each other could change things enough so we remember our place in all this. (pssst we not separate, just a thought)
as always
scott gianola
the grumpy barita
The citizens of San Juan County are not powerless. We can embrace positive change.
Concerns for humans, pets and fragile species in our environs place the burden on our shoulders to find an alternative to explosions on the fourth.
Fireworks without explosive noise or laser shows are great alternatives. Let the celebrations continue.
https://travel.excite.co.uk/town-in-italy-starts-using-silent-fireworks-as-a-way-of-respecting-their-animals-N52632.html
Miles and I were just talking about this last night Merry, while listening to all the extra explosions from private areas around Westsound and Shaw. It also went on the night of July third. Wouldn’t it be better to use the money spent each year on fireworks in Eastsound on something special that our village of Eastsound could permanently use?
As I drive around the Island I see posted on small white signs with red lettering ‘ALL FIREWORKS PROHIBITED. IT’S THE LAW’. Saw one in front of the fire hall today and one that folks will see while coming off the ferry.
Well, if it’s the law then why is it not being enforced? Perhaps someone from the Sheriff’s office or the OIFR can explain this. I share Cathy’s feelings. Thank you.
Thank you, Cathy. I was encouraged to hear that the Oystercatchers and their chick survived the noise ordeal, but I was so concerned for them that I could not go and enjoy the lights this year, just sat home listening to the booms, both legal and then illegal ones. I am gratified to read that most of the comments here are supporting your views, which echo my own.
In the Deceleration of July 4, 1976 we then broken off from the British empire, were 13 states.
Listen I understand some who would be having a hard time with this but this is tradition.
You have taken the bomber planes out of the 4th of July parade as it offend you. Again a time honored tradition.
Yet men wearing pink with their asses hanging out with no cover is applauded. This is ok but our history is stomped on?
This is about freedom, the fireworks are a time honored tradition. Teach of the past as to not repeat it.
For those who have served and died for our freedom please understand the fireworks are for everyone.
You come here you love it then you want to change it? I have never been an US and Them kind of person here on Orcas. I have always welcomed those who are new, but understand I will fight for tradition.
I very rarely make statements like this however I am tired of sitting back while people feel it is their right to speak for those of us that LOVE the fireworks.
Light show or fire works there will still be those who are shooting them off illigally. So you know who they are, you are their neighbors, Make them stop.
Alexander Conrad …thank you for calling me on my stereotype of China. I apologize, that was not my intent. I know the Chinese have a brilliant and historic tradition/culture of fireworks. The info, about the immense volume they produce and use, is according to several sources. I am far from any expert. Just a concerned citizen. And thank you for enlightening me on regulation and restriction changes for fireworks use in many parts of China. Bravo! That makes them perhaps ahead of us. Great, now let’s continue the conversation, perhaps with the C of C? Traditions worth saving, like this celebration, can indeed be tweaked a bit, rethink it. That is why we as a county no longer have the tradition of slave labor, nor women and children as second class citizens.
Melissa if you spent one fourth of July with my little Leo you might change your mind because it would break your heart. We take him as far away as possible from all possible fireworks but no place is safe with the illegal ones also going off. We have tried the Thunder shirts, Rescue Remedy, even playing fireworks over the computer and making them louder and louder leading up to the fourth and none of it has helped. The pure terror he feels is something I wouldn’t wish on an enemy. If he could crawl out of his own skin he would. For him it is fight or flight and he chooses flight so you can’t hold him and console him because confining him makes it worse. Last year he somehow managed to get out the sliding glass door and scale a four and a half foot fence and was gone. Took off up Buck Mountain from our house across from Ship Bay and it took forever after they stopped for him to let us come anywhere near him. If we tried he ran farther and farther. Now we take him to the quietest place we can only to come home and have a neighbor set off something that sounds like dynamite exploding. It’s heartbreaking, especially when there are alternatives that are just as beautiful if not more so but without the noise.