— a review by Margie Doyle, reprinted from March 18 upon request —

The Orcas Center production of “True West” as directed by Robert Hall is a funny, realistic and heart-breaking examination of the most primal relationship, that of siblings.

On Opening Night of “True West” at the Orcas Center Black Box, Kelly Toombs and Kevin Doyle expressed their brotherly love and frustration with an ease and authenticity as if they were born to it, not acting it. As they danced that sibling survival competition, there were moments of gut-wrenching tension, anxious foreboding and tears. They embodied the braggadocio and yearning that brothers bring to their embrace, especially portrayed in the beginning choreography (designed by Tiffaney Loney), the most masculine dance I’ve ever seen.

Jim Shaffer-Bauck as Saul Kimmer brought comic relief even as he became the wedge between the brothers, whose lives and personas were exchanged back and forth. But more than challenge a sense of reality, this juxtaposition made me almost feel like a helpless bystander watching the characters play out their deal with the devil, one character ceding his personality to the other.

Robert Hall deserves high praise not only as director of this outstanding cast, but also as set designer in the spare room of the Black Box. With the assistance of Jake Perrine, Hall has created a realistic, authentic set against a backdrop of stark western desert photography with the “high lonesome” music of the best country western singers. His artistic vision, and his confidence in letting his actors “have their head” are the marks of an accomplished and soulful director.

Though the play revolves around the brothers’ lifelong conflict, it never dissolves into an endurance match for the audience, partly due to Shepherd’s great, often poetic writing, but even more due to Toombs’ and Doyle’s wholeheartedly giving themselves to portray two men who are intimately connected, who know each other like the back of their hands, yet who can’t work out their envy of and admiration for each other. No one can hurt you like a brother; no rejection is felt more strongly than that by your sister. When siblings say, “Why aren’t you more like me?” they are really saying, “I wish I could be more like you.”

Aaimee Johnson as the mother, and Tom Fiscus and Steve Henigson as Mystery Man #1 and #2 fully support the drama, but this play is an actor’s showcase for the roles of the brothers — Toombs and Doyle are brilliantly sensitive and authentic. Orcas residents are extraordinarily fortunate to be able to partake of this high-quality production of a quintessential American drama. They should see and support this local cast who bring heroic — and tragic– stature to the Everymen of “True West.”

“True West” plays at the Orcas Center Black Box Theater at 7:30 p.m. March 18-19, and March 24, 25 and 26. It is sponsored by Sircely Marketing and Design and Orcas Center Trustee John Bric and Alison Weir. Advance tickets are available through orcascenter.org

**If you are reading theOrcasonian for free, thank your fellow islanders. If you would like to support theOrcasonian CLICK HERE to set your modestly-priced, voluntary subscription. Otherwise, no worries; we’re happy to share with you.**